Tossup

A character created by this philosopher describes nature as a “great machine” and analogizes (-5[1])it to a house in two presentations of the argument from design. (10[1]-5[1])This philosopher argued that there will always be more evidence for the laws of nature than for individual (10[1])miracles. (10[2])Contra (10[3])Spinoza, (10[2])this (10[1])philosopher wrote, (10[1])“reason (10[1])is, (10[1]-5[1])and (10[1])ought (10[1])only (10[2])to be, (10[2])the slave of the (10[3])passions.” (10[4]-5[1])According (10[2])to this (10[1])philosopher’s (10[1])“guillotine,” (-5[1])moral (10[2])“ought” (10[3])statements (10[2])cannot (10[1])be derived (10[3])from factual (10[1])“is” (10[2])statements. (10[2])This philosopher’s Enquiry (10[3])confusingly (10[1]-5[1])argues that someone can imagine (10[1])a “missing shade (10[1])of blue.” (10[11]-5[1])For (10[1])10 points, (10[1])name this empiricist (-5[1])philosopher of the Scottish Enlightenment. (10[6])■END■ (10[26]0[7])

ANSWER: David Hume [or David Home; accept Hume’s guillotine]
<Edinburgh B, Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentPositionValue
Aditya KoushikStanford BUCSC13-5
Jayden NgoKentuckyMichigan B25-5
Pratham BhanushaliWVU BMichigan D2510
Kevin ZhengMichigan APittsburgh4310
Arhith DharaendraGeorgia Tech BAlabama A4410
Pen HughesEdinburgh CEdinburgh D4410
Nikola WuUCLA DUC Santa Barbara4510
Nick SmemoeUNC AVCU A4510
Liam MarklandAlberta ATexas4510
Alex ColeridgeDurham BDurham D4610
Fintan ThomasCambridge ESouthampton4610
Towery McNeilMississippi State AChipola College4710
Derek AldridgeWilliam & Mary AWilliam & Mary C4910
Josh MorrisBristolImperial C5010
Harry FinesYorkEdinburgh A5110
Tom BlytheCambridge DLSE51-5
Bryce YoungerBoise StateAlberta B5210
James MeekGeorge Mason ARowan5310
Margaret WithersGeorge Mason BGeorge Mason C5410
Merrick HillIowa StateWisconsin B5410
Liam RojasVirginia AVirginia Tech C5610
Kevin LiuMaryland ANYU B5610
Oliver ThompsonCWRU DOhio State D6010
Michael AiWilliams ATufts A6010
Yuxuan LuVanderbilt AAuburn B6010
Suren GrigorianBerkeley Mighty MinerBerkeley Archer Queen6110
Terrence HanUCLA BUCLA A6110
Brian HobmannUCLA FUSC A61-5
Devito StevanusMcGill BMcGill C6110
Bharath RamGeorgia Tech AAuburn C6110
Charlie RuffMcGill AOttawa D6210
Walter CarsonNCSU BUNC C6210
Sebastian LlacaWisconsin ASt. Thomas6410
Aedan CooperOttawa AMcGill E6510
Hayden WillettPurdue BIllinois Blue66-5
Brooks PhillipsAuburn AClemson A6710
Joel KimClemson BVanderbilt B6710
Rishi MathurClaremont BUSC B6810
Wyatt JohnsonCWRU BLouisville C6810
Reed SextonMichigan CCWRU C6810
Charlie WeaverVirginia Tech BTusculum A6910
Dashiell HelmerWisconsin CMichigan Tech6910
James O'ReillyArizona State AWashington Masu7010
Kelvin NiNYU ARutgers C7210
James ZhaoVanderbilt CGeorgia Tech E7210
Danny CutbillRIT ARIT B7210
Alexander RuttenColumbia AMaryland C7410
Gavin ChenVassar ALehigh B7510
Lulu AndersonSheffield BEdinburgh B7510
Yiwei JiangNYU CRutgers A7610
Thaddeus HolmesDurham CSheffield A7610
Rohit ChintalaMaryland BPenn7910
Jonas CrossTennessee TechSewanne7910
Oliver MortenCardiffImperial A7910
Joseph WangUCLA EUCLA C80-5
Peter ZengOhio State ACWRU A8010
Tianyi ZhengUCSD BClaremont C8510
Sam AlahiIllinois OrangeWashU Grizzlers8810
Ritisha DeyStanford ABerkeley Boss Bandit90-5
Annika LarsonClaremont AUC Irvine9010
Ryan GomesFlorida Tech AFlorida Tech B9010
Snehan SarochLouisville AMichigan State B9010
Caleb HinesLiberty AJMU B9010
Jaden RupoloLiberty BWilliam & Mary B9010
Zachary BornsteinVirginia Tech ADuke A9010
Miranda ChenVassar BRutgers B9010
Matthew WestleyPurdue AChicago A9010
Camden WalkerWashU GrolarsIllinois Champaign9010
Alan FanWashington SteelheadWashington Atlantic9010
Jolie YehWarwickCambridge B9010
Alden ThompsonCarleton AOttawa C9110
James HaddixWashington StateWashington Chum9310
Arlene LopezStony BrookPrinceton96-5
Gabriel DoddsLiberty CUNC D10110
Lily HughbanksPurdue CIllinois Urbana10110
Trenton BurgessIndiana APurdue D10110
William EdwardsTennessee AEmory A10110
Andrew MillerBinghamton ABinghamton B10110
Gregory StoneESFCornell B10110
Vijay HansBerkeley Boss BanditStanford A10210
Aarav KakadUCLA CUCLA E10210
Chris ChangUSC AUCLA F10210
Nicholas NguyenFlorida BFlorida A10210
Addison WigginsSouth Florida AFlorida State A1020
Juan LandaetaFlorida State ASouth Florida A1020
Peyton LeggUCF AERAU Daytona A10210
Brody JohnsonLouisville BWVU A10210
Thomas JenkinsMichigan BKentucky10210
Miles SpielerOhio State CMichigan State D10210
Alex GrigoriadesLehigh ARutgers D1020
Alex WongRutgers DLehigh A1020
Vihaan JimPrincetonStony Brook10210
Eric MorshedJohns HopkinsColumbia B10210
Brian QianIllinois CanadaWilliam Woods University A10210
Grace EarlyIowa AIndiana B10210
Austin TranRose-Hulman AIowa B10210
Kevin YangIllinois BluePurdue B10210
Anneke StracksMacalesterMinnesota10210
Christopher BradleySouthern Connecticut State University ABoston University B10210
Ruby XiaArizona State BWashington Chinook10210
Henry Rutherford-BraunBritish Columbia BWashington Coho1020
Alan ZhangBritish Columbia CWashington Sockeye10210
Steven PanGeorgia Tech CGeorgia Tech F10210
Trey LewisSouth Carolina AGeorgia A10210
Richard D’AngeloTennessee BGeorgia Tech D10210
Tom Morris-JonesBirminghamImperial D1020
Ollie Glin-ConwayImperial DBirmingham1020
Kamil BoehmCambridge ACambridge C10210
Shlok DevLSECambridge D10210
Nayaaz HashimOxfordImperial B10210
Violet PageBinghamton CCornell D10210
Jonah McGinleyRochesterCornell C10210

Summary

TournamentEditionTUHConv. %Neg %Average Buzz
UK (North)UK5100%0%58.40
UK (South)UK888%13%81.57
Northern CaliforniaUS367%67%81.50
Southern CaliforniaUS7100%29%79.00
Eastern Canada (1)US4100%0%69.75
FloridaUS475%0%98.00
Great LakesUS10100%10%74.00
Lower Mid-AtlanticUS9100%0%72.44
Upper Mid-AtlanticUS1191%9%73.10
Upper Mid-AtlanticUS1100%0%102.00
MidwestUS9100%11%97.56
NorthUS4100%0%72.25
NortheastUS2100%0%81.00
PacificUS888%0%79.14
SoutheastUS12100%0%75.33
Upstate NYUS5100%0%95.60