Round 1: Tossup 2

A character created by this philosopher describes nature as a “great machine” and analogizes it to a house in two presentations of the argument from design. This philosopher argued that there will always be more evidence for the laws of nature than for individual miracles. (10[1])Contra Spinoza, (10[1])this philosopher wrote, “reason is, (10[1])and ought only to be, the slave of the passions.” According to this philosopher’s “guillotine,” moral “ought” statements cannot be derived from factual “is” (10[1])statements. (10[1])This philosopher’s Enquiry confusingly argues that someone can imagine a “missing shade of blue.” For 10 points, name this empiricist philosopher of the Scottish Enlightenment. ■END■

ANSWER: David Hume [or David Home; accept Hume’s guillotine]
<Edinburgh B, Philosophy> | Packet A
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Buzzes


Summary

TournamentEditionTUHConv. %Neg %Average Buzz
UK (North)UK5100%0%58.40
UK (South)UK888%13%81.57
Northern CaliforniaUS367%67%81.50
Southern CaliforniaUS7100%29%79.00
Eastern Canada (1)US4100%0%69.75
FloridaUS475%0%98.00
Great LakesUS10100%10%74.00
Lower Mid-AtlanticUS9100%0%72.44
Upper Mid-AtlanticUS1191%9%73.10
Upper Mid-AtlanticUS1100%0%102.00
MidwestUS9100%11%97.56
NorthUS4100%0%72.25
NortheastUS2100%0%81.00
PacificUS888%0%79.14
South CentralUS683%17%69.60
SoutheastUS12100%0%75.33
Upstate NYUS5100%0%95.60